Meowing Royalty

American Shorthair vs Bombay: Cat Breeds Comparison

Are you thinking about getting a new cat for your family but are torn between the American Shorthair and the Bombay? Keep reading to learn more about their similarities and differences.

American Shorthair and Bombay share the same origin. They both come from United States.

But honestly, breeds' origin doesn't reveal a lot about it, so please keep reading to learn more about these interesting breeds.

Although both breeds are very intelligent, it's important to consider their differences as well.

Here is some basic information about these breeds:

American Shorthair vs Bombay

American Shorthair
Length12 to 15 inches
Weight7 to 12 pounds
Overall Health
OriginUnited States
Life Span15 to 20 years
Bombay
Length13 to 20 inches
Weight8 to 15 pounds
Overall Health
OriginUnited States
Life Span12 to 20 years

American Shorthair vs Bombay Appearance

Bombays are longer.

Bombays have an average length of 13 to 20 inches and a weight of 8 to 15 pounds.

On the other side American Shorthairs, have a typical length of 12 to 15 inches and an average weight of 7 to 12 pounds.

Temperament

No doubt, each cat has its own temperament, but we'll try to make some generalizations and help you choose the breed that will fit

Affectionate with Family

Looking for a perfect family cat?

Well, we'd strongly advise to choose Bombay over American Shorthair.

Bombays love their people, and being a part of a family is something that helps them thrive.

American Shorthairs, on the other hand, are more of an independent type, that will prefer to stay silent in the corner, or their spot and monitor closely what is happening around them.

This doesn’t mean that there is no love toward humans but instead means that they prefer moments of solitude. You can still expect American Shorthairs to come to you for cuddles - at their own pace.

Kid-Friendly

Owning a feline and having a kid can be challenging but also so much rewarding. This is especially true if you get a American Shorthair or a Bombay because you will enjoy watching your kid growing with them together.

These breeds are major kids lovers, and describing them only as kid-friendly isn't enough.

Both breeds will monitor kids closely whenever you leave the room.

With so kid-friendly breeds around, your kid can easily learn how to behave around cats, and even how to train them. Treats can do wonders, even with cats.

Friendly Toward Strangers

Surprisingly, some cats are more than fond of strangers. They may not show their affection toward strangers like dogs do, but they have their share of showing friendliness toward strangers.

Cats will respond well to strangers when they feel safe. Both breeds will be polite, calm, and friendly toward strangers who treat them right.

In practice, this means that strangers who approach either American Shorthairs or Bombays may expect a friendly greeting.

If you don't mind having a cat who isn't scared of people, you may welcome these breeds into your home.

Just a word of caution: cats that are friendly with strangers and live in indoors on a terrace should have a safe area covered with a cat net. If you are a social butterfly with frequent visitors, both breeds will value the crowd.

Pet Friendly

Cats being generally friendly is one thing, but being friendly toward other pets is a completely different thing.

This trait must be taken into account if you've got another pet, so let's see do these breeds compare.

Bombays are generally more pet friendly than American Shorthairs.

Cats usually tolerate dogs because they are not so territorial beings as dogs are, but make sure that their introduction is done safely.

If you notice your feline moving away from pets, do not force them to mingle, or spend time together. As a general rule, cats and birds shouldn't be under the same roof.

Potential for Playfulness

If your future cat's playfulness is an important thing for you, be sure to read this carefully.

Let's get straight to the point:

Bombays are more playful, and they will require you to invest some time in keeping them entertained, otherwise they might get bored and eventully destructive.

American Shorthairs aren't described by feline lovers as a breed of high playfulness, so if you're looking for a more laid-back breed for your appartment, they might be a great choice.

General Health

Both American Shorthairs and Bombays are known for being healthy. In general, cats should reach their senior years without major issues, as long as you deal with responsible breeders and provide regular veterinarian check-ups.

A healthy diet, proper grooming, and exercise should keep your feline in top shape.

Although American Shorthair and Bombay are recognized as healthy breeds, health problems may occur during their lifetime. Eye problems, kidney issues, diarrhea, diabetes, and many other issues may appear. Prevention is the key when it comes to keeping them healthy, so stick to regular veterinarian check-ups.

Grooming

Grooming cats is never easy since felines are not known as creatures that love being handled. Some cats may be more tolerant if they are not demanding grooming-wise. If you want a cat like this one, you should stay away from American Shorthairs and Bombays as they are hard to groom.

Brushing is a mandatory part of every health routine, but it's far from being the only section. Cat grooming includes also trimming nails, hair trimming and combining, shaving mats if needed, and bathing only when needed.

American Shorthairs or Bombay are typical representatives of breeds being hard to handle when grooming. They are not enjoying when being handled and it usually leads to some disturbance and poor grooming outcomes.

These breeds shouldn’t be your option for ownership if you find it hard to deal with the grooming process.

Shedding

Nobody enjoys the facts cats shed, but if you hate that, you should probably stick to Bombays, as they shed less than American Shorthairs.

However, don't forget that all cats need regular brushing, but how often depends on the breed.

Cats are not too fond of being handled, so invest in high-quality (and proper) grooming tools to make the brushing process easier and short.

Tendency to Vocalize

American Shorthair and Bombay are known as breeds with a medium tendency to be vocal. Being talkative isn't something that they do all day long.

They may meow to get attention, food, or just to express their affection toward you.

With these breeds around you will get enough sleep.

If you are on the lookout for a breed that loves to purr, but won't disturb you by being too vocal, you are on the right track.

Intelligence

It's a well-known fact that cats are among the most intelligent creatures alive. They are smart to react instinctively, fast to hunt, and smart to hide in a matter of seconds.

Intelligence is a factor to consider when getting a cat. If you want a super smart cat that can be trained but is also independent enough to learn on its own, both breeds are great to have around.

Did you know that cat intelligence is ranked on their sociability and willingness to interact with their owners?

These breeds are fast to interact, communicate, and demand a lot of your time and playtime to thrive.

The Final Word

We hope our American Shorthairs vs Bombays comparison helped you to choose the right breed for you.

You can use the tool below to make a new comparison.

Select first breed:

Select second breed: